Personalized ELA 10: A Flex-Blended, Mastery-Based English Course


A redesign of 10th grade English at Rapid City High School that gave every module the same routine, so students could move at their own pace and choose where the course went.

  • Project Type: Classroom redesign (curriculum, instruction, and assessment)
  • Audience or Client: English 10 (A and B) students at Rapid City High School, then the alternative program for Rapid City Area Schools
  • Timeline: 2021-2022 school year
  • Role: Classroom teacher and course designer
  • Format or Deliverables: A 15-module Canvas course with three core modules and four emphasis pathways, a consistent eight-step module routine, mastery-based grading, daily goal sheets, a board timer for the class period, and a full course explanation document

The Situation

The traditional approach to 10th grade English wasn’t working for my students at Rapid City High School, the district’s alternative program at the time. Students arrived with very different skills, came to class on different schedules, and needed different amounts of support from day to day. Homework wasn’t allowed, so everything had to happen in the room. Any plan where the whole class moved through the same lesson on the same day would leave some students bored and others lost, and it would leave anyone who missed a few days without a clear way back in.

The Approach in Brief

I rebuilt the course around three ideas: personalized learning, a flex-blended model, and mastery-based grading. All instruction, content, and assignments lived in Canvas, so a student could pick up wherever they were. In-person time went to check-ins, small-group breakouts, and optional activities instead of whole-class lectures. Every module followed the same eight-step routine, and students could test out of a module at the start by showing mastery on a pre-assessment. After three core modules, each student chose one of four emphasis pathways for the rest of the course. The routine was what made the freedom manageable: once students knew the steps, they could work through very different content without needing me to walk them through it.

What Came Out of It

The course ran for the 2021-2022 school year with the full structure in place: 15 modules, four pathways, a single routine, and grades based only on mastery. I also wrote a full course explanation document that describes and justifies every piece of it. I didn’t keep outcome data from that year, so I can’t say how students did compared with earlier versions of the course. What I can say is that the structure held up for a full year in a setting where attendance and pace varied a great deal.

Key Takeaway

Personalization in a classroom depends on a structure students can learn once and rely on. The consistent routine was what let 15 modules and four pathways run at the same time without the course falling apart.


Deeper Context

The course drew on a few traditions at once. Personalized learning, which goes back to Rousseau, Dewey, and Montessori, aims to let each student shape their path, pace, and mode of learning. I treated it as an aspiration rather than something the course fully achieved.

Illustration with an arrow from "Traditional Learning," a teacher lecturing at a board to rows of students, to "Student-Centered Learning," a teacher surrounded by individual students with books and a laptop.

On blended learning, the course sat between a flipped classroom and a FLEX model. A full FLEX setup had been piloted at RCHS but wasn’t running that year, and with no homework allowed, “flipping” had to happen inside class time. The Canvas course was the backbone, and the room was arranged for different kinds of work: a class library, a makerspace, a coffee station with board games, a collaboration table, and tables and cushions with no seating chart.

Top-down map of the classroom: a class library in one corner, a coffee and board game station in another, a makerspace along one wall, a round collaboration table, four hexagonal tables in the center, cushion spots along the walls, and a teacher corner with the board.

Mastery-based grading had to fit inside a traditional gradebook. Assessments were scored on a four-point scale, and only two items could affect a module grade: the pre-assessment or the final assessment. A 3 (mastered) became 90%, a 4 (beyond mastery) became 100%, and anything below that stayed incomplete until the student revised it. Everything else was scored for feedback, not for points.

The Journey

The first three modules were the same for everyone. After that, students picked an emphasis pathway (Shakespeare and Criticism, Language, Multicultural Literature, or Research and Information) and completed three more modules in it. Students were exempt from the other pathways’ work. Each pathway was tied to career clusters, and students who finished one received a letter of recommendation describing what they had shown in that area. Some of the course outcomes were unusual for a 10th grade class, such as using Robert’s Rules or another protocol to run a discussion, tracing the etymology of words, analyzing how Ted Chiang’s “Story of Your Life” shows linguistic relativity, and tracing themes across Oceti Sakowin speeches and documents.

Diagram of the course path. Three core modules lead from Start Course to a split into four color-coded pathways, each with modules 4 through 6 ending in Course Complete: Shakespeare and Criticism, Language, Multicultural Lit, and Research and Info.

Every module followed the same eight steps, each marked with its own emoji so students could tell them apart at a glance: 1) read the overview, 2) try the pre-assessment, 3) research and complete the lesson, 4) share that research in the Learning Community, 5) complete at least one item from the Practice Menu, 6) score 5 out of 5 on the Check for Understanding, 7) score a 3 or 4 on the assessment, and 8) fill out a reflection survey. A student who scored 3 or higher on the pre-assessment skipped straight to the end. I taught this routine explicitly at the start of the year, and after the first module students knew what to expect from every module that followed.

Flowchart of the eight-step module routine, each step with an emoji: 1) read the overview, 2) try the pre-assessment, where a 3 out of 4 or higher tests out of the module, 3) research and complete the lesson, 4) share research in the Learning Community, 5) complete at least one Practice Menu item, 6) score 5 out of 5 on the Check for Understanding, 7) score 3 out of 4 on the assessment, with arrows back to study and relearn, and 8) fill out the reflection survey to complete the module.

Each step was built to carry part of the load. The overview page opened with a short video of me explaining the outcome and why it mattered. The lesson asked students to write down what they already knew, come up with at least five research questions, find answers in whatever way worked for them, and summarize what they learned. The Learning Community hid other students’ posts until a student posted their own, and then I added my own summary with study tips. The Practice Menu offered several ways to practice and let students propose their own. The Check for Understanding had five auto-scored questions plus three reflection questions, and students could retake it as often as they needed. For the final assessment, students could show mastery any way they liked as long as it met a minimum, and they made interviews, dioramas, short films, op-eds, board games, and self-published poetry. The RPG Maker games I built as unit hooks were part of this course too.

The daily structure mattered as much as the modules. Each period ran on a video timer on the board with my recorded announcements, moving from finding a spot, to a four-minute talk from me, to making a plan, to 22 minutes of guided work with check-ins, a short break, 25 minutes of independent work, and a minute each for reflection and cleanup. Students started each period by filling out a dry-erase goal sheet with what they would finish that day and how much help they wanted: just a check-in, help with something specific, or space. That last option gave students a way to ask for privacy at their own table without making a scene of it. In the first weeks, short lessons on learner agency skills such as resilience, goal setting, and follow-through gave everyone a shared language for how the class worked.

The Work Itself

The full course explanation below walks through every element of the course with screenshots from the Canvas modules, photos of the room, and the reasoning behind each choice.

What I’d Change

The hardest balance was between flexibility and structure. The routine solved a lot of it, but students working at very different paces in one room still pulled my attention in many directions, and the check-in block was often too short to reach everyone who needed me. Equitable access to technology was a constant issue, and so was fitting mastery grading into a gradebook built to rank students.

I’d also keep better notes. I didn’t track outcomes that year, and I’d want at least a record of what students said about the routine and the pathways, so a case like this could point to their experience and not only to the design.

Finally, I’d justify the design differently. The course explanation backs nearly every element with a Hattie effect size. At the time, that was the expected way to argue for a design, but I’ve since come to think that “what works” numbers can’t answer the more important question of what a course is for. If I wrote the explanation today, I’d start from the purposes behind each choice and treat the research as one input rather than the argument.

Several pieces of this course carried into my later work with adult learners: a consistent routine across modules, pre-assessments that let experienced people skip what they already know, and practice menus that give learners a choice of how to practice.

Connections

For the games I built as hooks for this course, see Video Games as Hooks for Project-Based ELA at an Alternative High School. For why I’m wary of letting “what works” stand in for purpose, see Research-Based Is Not a Purpose. For the JavaScript tool I built for personalized reading practice plans, see Reflections on “Why All Teachers Should Code.”

If you’re building a personalized or mastery-based course of your own, I’d like to hear about it. You can reach me at licht.education@gmail.com, and there are more tools, articles, and resources at bradylicht.com.


Discover more from Brady Licht

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.