Weekly Socratic Seminars for Grades 7-12 in Rural South Dakota


A first-year teacher’s weekly discussion routine in Bison, built up over a year with worksheets, a text selection that kept shifting, and sentence starters that came halfway through when students needed them.

  • Project Type: Classroom practice and instructional resource development
  • Audience or Client: ELA students in grades 7 through 12 at Bison School in rural northwest South Dakota; later, other teachers through the Socrates’ Chalkboard website
  • Timeline: 2017-2018 school year, with resources shared online through 2018-2019
  • Role: Classroom teacher and materials designer
  • Format or Deliverables: A weekly Socratic seminar routine, a seminar worksheet, rhetoric slips (sentence starters for discussion), seminar printables for specific texts, and the Socrates’ Chalkboard resource site

The Situation

My first year of teaching was in Bison, a small town in rural northwest South Dakota, where I taught ELA across grades 7 through 12. The classes were small, and many students did not think of themselves as academic, did not plan to continue school after graduating, or were anxious about speaking in front of others. I wanted a way to build reading, thinking, and discussion skills that would work across six grade levels and wouldn’t depend on students already seeing themselves as people who talk about texts.

The Approach in Brief

I made Socratic seminars a weekly routine in every class. Before each seminar, students read and annotated a short text and wrote their own questions on a worksheet. On the day, they reread it, moved into a square of tables, and talked about it with as little steering from me as I could manage. Afterward, they reflected and set goals for the next one. The texts varied a lot from week to week: fables, poems, speeches, paintings, and songs. Halfway through the year, I added rhetoric slips, which were sentence starters for moves like paraphrasing, conceding a point, or politely disagreeing, because students needed more ways to put their thinking into words.

What Came Out of It

The seminars ran every week for the full year. I didn’t keep data from those classes, so what I have is what I saw. Students who struggled to analyze a text early in the year were taking different perspectives and building on each other’s ideas by the end. That included students who weren’t headed to more school and students who didn’t see themselves as academic. A few students with serious social anxiety, and the para who worked with them, started sharing a thought here and there after a few weeks. In a 10th grade seminar on a painting, the class was reading it as gloomy until one student pointed out that something looking sad to us now doesn’t mean it was sad at the time. They compared it to the doilies and furniture in a grandparent’s house, which look old to us but wouldn’t have felt old when they were new. Other students picked up that idea, and the discussion opened up from there.

Key Takeaway

Doing the same discussion routine every week gave students who didn’t think of themselves as academic enough repetition to find their footing. The structure stayed the same, so the texts could change freely.


Deeper Context

The small, rural setting was part of why this worked. Classes were small enough that everyone could sit in one square and hear each other, and students had known each other for years, which made it easier to take a risk in front of the group once the routine felt familiar. The same closeness could make starting slow, since a student who talked a lot in one class might be quiet in another with older or younger students. Teaching six grade levels as a first-year teacher also meant I needed one routine I could run everywhere instead of six different discussion formats.

Classroom set up for a seminar, with tables pushed together into a large square so every seat faces the middle, and a worksheet and pencil at each place.

The Journey

Each seminar had three parts. Before it, students used a worksheet to prepare: a short guide to seminar norms (come prepared, use evidence, explain your answers, only one person speaks at a time, encourage others), space for their own questions about the text, and a box for what they were still wondering about. On the day, they reread the text, moved into the square, and talked. Afterward, they wrote a reflection and set a goal for their participation next time.

Socratic seminar worksheet with a guide listing seminar norms, fields for name, teacher, period, date, and text, a large box for questions for the group, and a smaller box labeled Things that I'm still wondering.

Text selection was where I learned the most. I chose a wide range on purpose, from Aesop’s “The Fox and the Grapes” for younger students to section 6 of Whitman’s “Song of Myself,” Thomas Cole’s The Course of Empire paintings, and Sojourner Truth’s “Ain’t I a Woman?” for older ones. Some weeks I paired texts. With the 8th grade class, one week we discussed a retelling of the tortoise and the hare, and the next week we read a follow-up story about what happened after, which they found really interesting. Not every choice worked. One week I gave every student a different article on the same topic, hoping they’d bring different angles. Without a shared text to start from, the discussion never really got going, and that showed me how much the seminars depended on everyone holding the same piece.

The seminar that taught me the most about my own role used Sam Cooke’s “A Change Is Gonna Come” with my 7th or 8th grade class. Students talked about what they thought the song represented, but they were struggling, and I realized the problem was my text selection: they didn’t have the historical context to read it. So I paused the seminar halfway, gave them some background on what was changing at the time and some of the people involved, and then let them go back to it. The second half was a much richer discussion. That pause became something I’d use again whenever a text needed more grounding than I’d given it.

The rhetoric slips came about halfway through the year. I based them on the templates in Graff and Birkenstein’s They Say / I Say, which gives writers ready-made moves for entering an academic conversation. Each slip offered one discussion move with a couple of sentence frames, such as quoting or paraphrasing someone else, finding consensus, conceding a point, asking for clarification, or politely disagreeing. They gave quieter students a way into the discussion, and because the same moves work in writing, they carried over into students’ essays.

Six rhetoric slips with sentence frames: Quote Others/Text, Paraphrase Others/Text, Find Consensus, Concede a Point, Ask for Clarification, and Politely Disagree.

The Work Itself

After that year, I put the materials on a website called Socrates’ Chalkboard so other teachers could use them. The site ran for about a year before my master’s program and other work made it too hard to keep up, but the materials are still available below: the seminar worksheet, the rhetoric slips, three seminar printables for specific texts, and the full resource folder.

Home page of the Socrates' Chalkboard website, noting it is a no-longer-active recreation of the original site, with a section titled Wisdom from Socrates.

Socrates’ Chalkboard resource folder (Google Drive)

What I’d Change

I’d start smaller. Asking every class to jump into a full seminar in the first weeks made for slow starts. Beginning with smaller discussion groups, letting students watch a strong discussion before joining one, and practicing specific moves one at a time would have helped students get comfortable sooner.

I’d introduce the rhetoric slips from the beginning instead of halfway through. They were among the most useful pieces of the whole routine, and the students who needed them most would have had them for a full year.

I’d plan more carefully for access, too. Some of my students were exchange students, and live translation tools and differentiated preparation materials would have given them a fuller part in the conversation. More visual supports would have helped others. I’d also keep notes on what students said in seminars, since moments like the doilies comparison are the best evidence I have, and I only have the ones I remember.

The website taught me a smaller lesson about sharing resources. Even good materials take steady time to maintain online, and a site that only one person runs won’t last longer than that person’s spare time.

Connections

For a later course where leading a discussion with Robert’s Rules or another protocol was a course outcome, see Personalized ELA 10: A Flex-Blended, Mastery-Based English Course. For a session built around structured discussion with adults instead of students, see the Keynote at the Black Hills Library Mini-Conference.

If you run seminars or structured discussions in your own classroom, I’d like to hear how they go. You can reach me at licht.education@gmail.com, and there are more tools, articles, and resources at bradylicht.com.


Discover more from Brady Licht

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.